The Giver by Lois Lowry

This is a very fascinating book, that kept me drawn in until the very end. I loved the alternate, "perfect" world Lois Lowry portrayed. I do, however, believe some parts of this book are a bit crazy and scary to picture, based on my own reactions. I can also see how this book could be so controversial,especially in religious contexts, because it does not believe in a higher power that controls all. This society has the power to change colors and memories, or chose who is worthy of life. After reading this book, I found myself wondering if it was really a children's book, and what age range it was suggested for. I do not think I would know how to handle a book with such strong content and a strong message at age 11. I think that this is a great, moving book, but I would not recommend it for anyone younger than sixth grade.
When I read this book, it kind of reminded me of our lives in America, and how we have certain stages we are expected to go through, like the children in the book. I feel like there is a certain age were we are expected to give up our "comfort item" because it is no longer acceptable, and an age when we are supposed start riding a bike. When we turn 16 we are able to ride a car, and when we turn 18 we are expected to get a job, move out, or start college. I know a lot of people who would be relieved if they were told what career would be perfect for them, or who their perfect match is, so they did not have to worry about it or struggle with it themselves.
After thinking about this book for awhile, I have came to the conclusion that we all go through what Jonah went through when he turned twelve. Usually it is not until eighteen or even twenty-two years old, but eventually we all have a time when we realize that what we thought was a perfect world, is really messed up and clouded with crazy people. Leaving small town Iowa for Iowa City, arguably one of the most liberal cities in Iowa was a challenge. Realizing that teachers you once looked up to, are not as perfect as they seemed. Finding love and enduring heartbreak, while not as bad as never having the capabilities for such emotions, plague a lot of people during this time. Maybe having the option to choose your own identity and choices is what makes good people so special.